Fitting the profile.
I had my doubts about finding examples of neglecting dis-confirming evidence in
studies about messy desks and creativity on the web, but I figured I might as
well look. What I did find was a series of articles on birth order, and why, contrary
to accumulated evidence, people, including scientists, continue to find a correlation
between birth order and certain personality traits. Judith Rich Harris, in Why
Do People Believe that Birth Order Has Important Effects on Personality?, brings numerous examples, including one
that, perhaps serendipitously, refers to messy desks.
Harris very clearly explains the general problem:
When faced with mixed evidence, people focus on the parts that confirm their beliefs and ignore the parts that don't. A believer in birth order who didn't happen to know the birth order of Bill Gates, the founder of Microsoft, might think he was a firstborn, because of his leadership ability and drive to succeed. A believer in birth order who happens to know that Bill Gates is the second of three siblings will focus on some other aspect of his personality, such as his openness to new ideas or his loyalty to old friends.
She then gives an example that deals with the quality of being well-organized,
or perfectionist:If the disconfirmatory evidence can't be ignored, it can be explained
away. Kevin Leman, who accurately describes himself as "North America's 'pop'
birth order psychologist" (1998, p. 13), believes that firstborns are meticulous,
well-organized perfectionists, but was undismayed when he encountered a firstborn
with a messy desk. "Your desk is sloppy," he observed, "but can
you find what you need on it?" "Of course," was the firstborn's
reply. Satisfied, Leman went on to speculate: "My guess is you are something
of a perfectionist and perfectionists are known for having sloppy desks as a means
of covering their discouragement for not always having life go just the way they
want it" (1998, p. 93). It's a win-win setup for Leman: If a firstborn has
a neat desk, it's because he's a perfectionist, and that confirms Leman's theory.
If a firstborn doesn't have a neat desk, it's because he's covering up his discouragement,
and Leman's theory is again confirmed.
I suppose that if a first born doesn't have a desk at all, it's a sign that he
or she is in denial.
Go to: Creative Clutter, or
Go to: But you can, you can!